A Court Just Told Amazon Its AI Shopping Ban Won’t Stick

Back in March, a federal judge told Perplexity to stop letting its Comet browser buy things on Amazon. Amazon’s argument leaned on a decades-old computer hacking law, the kind written for break-ins, not for an AI agent finishing a shopping list on someone’s behalf.

On Tuesday, the Ninth Circuit threw that injunction out. The court’s reasoning is worth sitting with. It isn’t Perplexity that accesses Amazon’s servers, the judges said. It’s the person who told Comet to go buy the thing. Comet is carrying out an errand a shopper asked for, using an account that shopper already had permission to use. Where the law was genuinely unclear about who counts as the one doing the accessing, the court declined to stretch it to cover Perplexity.

The judges were careful to call this ruling narrow, and they’re right to hedge. Nobody has really settled who is responsible when an agent acts on your behalf online, and the panel said as much outright, noting that the law here will keep changing as more of these cases show up. The underlying lawsuit between Amazon and Perplexity is still going. This ruling just means Comet keeps working while it plays out.

Still, this lands as a real answer to a question that’s going to come up over and over as more of us hand small tasks off to agents instead of doing them ourselves by hand. If I ask an assistant to compare prices and buy the cheapest option, that purchase is still mine. The tool doing the clicking doesn’t change whose decision it was.

Good to see a court say that plainly instead of leaving the question hanging for another year while every retailer and every AI company guesses at where the line sits.

——

Follow: @Ali Demi
Book your free AI clarity call, NOW!
https://buff.ly/TpWy277

——

Sources:
https://news.bloomberglaw.com/us-law-week/perplexity-overturns-amazon-ban-on-ai-shopping-bot-on-appeal
https://www.engadget.com/2230471/perplexity-has-successfully-overturned-amazon-injunction-on-its-ai-shopping-bot/
https://www.tftc.io/ninth-circuit-cfaa-amazon-perplexity-comet-browser-ruling

Repost this. Thanks.